Mass and Matter

Many people, who vaguely remember their schoolmathematics has refined and corrected Newtonian
physics classes, would have some troublelaws.
differentiating between "mass" and "matter".It is the bedrock of modern physics. Yet it also
Modern physics, however, is beginning to showstates (and has shown experimentally) that a
that these two words really refer to twobody can exist simultaneously in two or more
different physical manifestations. All matter thatplaces; it also avers that observation not only
we can perceive on earth, and all the billions ofmarks an object but actually brings it into being:
stars and galaxies that we can observe in thebefore the observation, there was no object.
sky, altogether make up less than 5% of theFurthermore, under certain conditions, the result
contents of the universe. More than 95% consistsof an action can be transmitted instantaneously to
of what is called "dark matter" and "dark energy",another place, no matter how far away.
that is to say matter and energy that is invisible.These weirdnesses in quantum mechanics will be
This dark matter can be detected only by itsdealt with separately in another article. They
gravitational pull on visible matter. "Visible" matterservce as a reminder that matter is much more
includes not only what we see in nature aroundmysterious than anyone imagined during the era
us, but also the gases that we do not seeof classical Newtonian physics, when the atom
directly. All this matter is atomic in structure, withwas thought to be the ultimate, indivisible little bit
almost all its mass in the atomic nucleus, that is inof ordinary matter. What is of interest here is
its protons and neutrons. These two particles, plusthat quantum mechanics realizes that, for all
some short-lived particles, are called baryons as apractical purposes, large bodies can be dealt with
group. Each of them consists of three quarks.according to the laws of classical physics.
What the invisible dark matter consists of isAs these bodies get smaller and smaller, down to
unknown. Physicists, however, are reasonablymolecules and then atoms, the weird effects
certain that by far the greater proportion of itincrease, because such particles can easily be put
must consist of non-baryonic particles, that is ofinto a wave form, which is the necessary
matter which does not have an atomic structure.preliminary to being in a "superposition state",
Speculation centers around the concept of a gaswhere such a particle can exist in two places at
of weakly interacting massive particles, or WIMPS.the same time.
These particles are purely hypothetical at theDown to and including the atom, however, matter
moment. If they are ever discovered, theparticles are still well defined in space. With a
presently used Standard Model of particle physicsmodern scanning tunneling microscope (STM), we
would have to be extended to include them.can not only see individual atoms, but we can pick
So it seems that "dark matter" has mass,them up and move them around. The situation
because it exerts gravitational pull, but not whatgets much more difficult with subatomic particles,
we commonly call matter, which has an atomicwhich Heisenberg called "potentialities" or
structure. This atomic matter, which not too long"probabilities", rather than well-defined realities.
ago was thought to represent the entireAt the beginning of the modern age of physics, in
structure of the universe, is now found to be athe 1920s, when it became obvious that
somewhat rare (less than 5% of the total)subatomic particles were not simply very small
combination of mass and forces which workbits of matter, Bertrand Russell grumped in his
together to form an atom, that is the basicOutline of Philosophy that, "For ought we know an
building block of all matter. The forces involvedatom may consist entirely of the radiations that
here are primarily the strong nuclear force, whichcome out of it. It is useless to argue that
holds the quarks together in the protons andradiations cannot come out of nothing .... The idea
neutrons, and also holds the protons and neutronsthat there is a little hard lump there which is the
together in the nucleus of the atom.electron or the proton, is an illegitimate intrusion of
The other force involved in this uniquecommonsense notions derived from touch." It
combination of mass and force that constituteswas a hard time for scientific thinkers to make
the atom is the electromagnetic force, whichthe jump from classical Newtonian physics to the
interacts with electrically charged particles, like themodern age.
electron and the proton. The electromagneticToday, the results of quantum experiments leave
attraction between negatively charged electronsno doubt that what we call matter exists
and positively charged protons in the nucleussimultaneously in two states, one in wave form
causes the electrons to orbit the nucleus of the(where it can be in two places at once) and the
atom.other in particle form, where it can exist in only
As all solids, liquids and gases of our world areone place at a time. It is entirely our decision in
made up of an atomic structure, it might bewhich state we want to investigate a body.
easier to call all these "matter". Everything belowWhat this article suggests is that both mass and
the atomic horizon, particles such as protons,force are "dark" or invisible manifestations by
neutrons and quarks, could then be thought of asthemselves. Hence, what we call "dark matter"
consisting of "mass" There are also force particlesand "dark energy". The primal energy (to give it a
which carry mass, like the W and Z bosons. Whenname) which was exploded in the Big Bang and
it comes to "dark matter", of course, somethingfrom which the universe originated, is thought by
is involved which is different again. Not only in thismodern physics to have passed through
dark matter thought to have no atomic structure,something called the Higgs Field, from which it
but it is also thought to consist largely of WIMPS,emerged at different levels of energy.
that is non-baryonic particles, or particles which doFirst to emerge, at very high energy levels, were
not include the ordinary subatomic protons andthe force of gravity and the strong nuclear force.
neutrons.Below that came the electromagnetic force and
It is tempting, however, to use the term "matter"the weak nuclear force and still further down the
only for atomic matter and the term"mass" forenergy scale came the mass particles. A small
everything else on which gravity exerts anportion of these mass and force particles then
influence. When we know what "dark matter"combined to form the atomic structure of
actually consists of, it might be necessary atmatter, which we can perceive through our
some stage to divide the concept of mass yetsenses. Apart from that, only light (as it emerged
further.from the Higgs Field) could have been perceived
This conceptual difference between matter andby our senses, as part of the radio wave
mass is confirmed to some extent by the latestspectrum.
work in quantum mechanics, which otherwise hasSuch is the general framework around the origins
been rattling our conceptual cages in a mostof mass, matter and force which modern physics
disquieting manner for years. It should beis looking at today. How it all fits together, and
emphasized that quantum theory is unbelievablywhether these ideas will stand the test of time, is
successful. Every prediction it has ever made hassomething only the future can decide.
been proved by experiment and observation. Its